No subcontractor relationship should run on a handshake and a texted price, even one that has worked fine for ten years. A solid subcontractor agreement covers eight terms: scope, payment, insurance, indemnity, licensing, warranty, termination, and flow-down of your customer contract. Each one answers a question that otherwise gets answered in the middle of a dispute, usually by whoever remembers the conversation differently.
Picture a hypothetical Thursday afternoon on a kitchen remodel in Draper. Your electrical sub finished rough-in, and at the walkthrough the homeowner points out that half the outlets are in the wrong place. Your sub says the plans changed and nobody told him. You open the "agreement," which turns out to be an email with a dollar figure and the words "per our conversation." Nobody did anything wrong on purpose. The paper just never said who owned the problem.
Here are the eight terms that make that conversation shorter.
1. Scope of work
Describe exactly what the sub is doing, by reference to the plans, specs, and revision date. Say what's excluded, too. Most scope fights come from the gray zone: who patches the drywall after the plumber cuts in, who hauls debris, who pulls the permit. Add a simple change order rule: no extra work gets paid unless it's approved in writing before it starts.
2. Payment, and the pay-when-paid question
Spell out the price, the billing schedule, retention, and what the sub has to turn in to get paid (lien waivers, invoices, payroll records if you need them).
Then decide what happens when your customer pays late. Two clauses sound alike and work very differently:
Pay-when-paid sets the timing. You pay the sub within a set time after you're paid, and if the owner never pays, you still owe the sub within a reasonable time.
Pay-if-paid shifts the risk. Your customer's payment is a condition of the sub getting paid at all.
California and Utah part ways here. In Wm. R. Clarke Corp. v. Safeco Insurance Co. (1997), the California Supreme Court held that pay-if-paid clauses are unenforceable because they work as an indirect waiver of a subcontractor's mechanic's lien rights. A genuine pay-when-paid clause addresses timing rather than eliminating payment, but don't assume it allows an indefinite delay. California also has a prompt payment rule: unless otherwise agreed in writing, a contractor generally must pass a sub its share within seven days after receiving a progress payment. The clock runs from your receipt of the progress payment, not from the sub's invoice. A violation can trigger a penalty of 2 percent per month, subject to the statute's good-faith dispute rules.
Utah regulates these clauses directly. Under Utah Code 13-8-4, a pay-if-paid clause generally isn't a defense to a sub's lien claim, and a sub can ask for the project financing information you've received, which you must provide before it signs. That lien protection doesn't apply to private residential work on four units or fewer, which covers most home remodels. Beyond the statute, Utah courts haven't settled whether every true pay-if-paid clause is enforceable, so don't assume the label will hold.
Utah also regulates retention on covered nonresidential commercial and industrial projects. Retention is generally capped at 5 percent, and once you receive released retention, you generally have 10 days to pay each sub its share. Separate rules allow specified withholding for breach, default, or incomplete work.
3. Insurance
List the coverage the sub must carry (general liability, auto, workers' compensation) with minimum limits. Require additional insured status under the policy itself, by a blanket provision or an endorsement, not just a name on a certificate, and require proof again at every renewal. A certificate of insurance is a snapshot. It shows what existed on the day it was printed.
4. Indemnity
An indemnity clause says the sub will cover losses caused by its work. Both states limit how far that can go.
In California, an indemnity clause can't cover a party's sole negligence or willful misconduct. For covered construction subcontracts entered into on or after January 1, 2013, Civil Code 2782.05 also limits clauses that shift liability and defense costs for another contractor's active negligence, willful misconduct, specified design defects, or matters outside the sub's scope. Different rules apply to certain residential projects and other contract types, so check which category the job falls in. Utah's statute generally voids construction indemnity clauses that make one party cover another party's fault. A Utah appellate court has held, though, that a separate requirement for the sub to buy additional insured coverage for you is a different promise and isn't void. Whether that coverage responds to a claim still depends on the policy and endorsement.
The practical fix in both states: tie the indemnity to losses "to the extent caused by" the sub's work, and back it with the insurance requirement.
5. Licensing
Require the sub to hold the right license for the work, keep it active the whole job, and tell you immediately if anything changes. Then check it yourself.
In California, the CSLB's online license check shows status, classifications, bond, and workers' comp information on file. A licensed contractor who contracts with an unlicensed one can face discipline. A contractor who wasn't properly licensed throughout work that required a license generally can't sue to collect for that work, getting licensed later doesn't automatically fix it, and the customer may be able to recover what it already paid. In Utah, licensing runs through DOPL, and hiring an unlicensed person to do work that requires a license is unlawful, subject to statutory exemptions and a limited exception for qualifying employees of licensed contractors.
6. Warranty
Your customer is going to call you, not your sub, when something fails eight months later. Make the sub's warranty run at least as long as the warranty you gave the customer, starting from the same date. Add a response time for callbacks and your right to fix it yourself and back-charge if the sub doesn't show.
7. Termination
Write down how either side can end the relationship. Most agreements need two paths:
For cause, with written notice and a short cure period, plus your right to finish the work and charge the sub the extra cost.
For convenience, which lets you end it for any reason, paying only for work properly completed to date.
Say what happens to materials on site and who keeps the plans and documents.
8. Flow-down
Your customer contract has obligations your sub needs to honor: schedule, safety rules, change order process, notice deadlines, and how disputes get resolved. A flow-down clause makes the sub bound to those terms for its portion of the work. Attach the relevant pages or give the sub a copy. A sub can't follow terms it has never seen.
If you haven't looked at your customer contract in a while, these seven clauses are a good companion read, since your subcontract should mirror them.
Where to start
Pull the agreement you use with your busiest sub and check it against these eight terms. Gaps are common. Most owners started with a template from a supplier or a peer and never went back to it. None of this is unusual, and it's all fixable with one good master agreement you reuse on every job.
This is part of our subcontractor and vendor risk pillar of the Clean Legal Bill of Health®.
Or work through it yourself with the Pillar 3 checklist ($67)
This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.