What every LLC operating agreement needs in Utah and California

Neither Utah nor California generally requires an LLC operating agreement to be in writing. An oral or implied agreement can still exist, but wherever the agreement leaves a gap, each state's default rules decide the result. In Utah those rules are in the Utah Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act, which moved from Title 48, Chapter 3a to Title 16, Chapter 20 of the Utah Code effective October 1, 2026. In California it's the California Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (Corporations Code section 17701.01 and following). A good written operating agreement replaces those defaults with the deal you and your partners made: who owns what, who decides what, how money comes out, and what happens when someone leaves.

The moment most owners find out

Picture two hypothetical partners who started a plumbing company eleven years ago. One put in most of the cash for the first trucks. The other ran the crews and built the customer list. They never signed an operating agreement because they trusted each other, and for a decade that worked.

Then a lender asks for the operating agreement as part of a line of credit renewal. There isn't one. Their CPA asks how profits are split, and the two partners give different answers. Nobody is angry yet. But for the first time they realize that wherever their handshake didn't cover something, or can't be proved, the state's rules fill the gap.

That's the most common way this comes up. It's rarely a fight. It's a document request.

What the default rules say

Here's a short tour of what applies when there's no agreement on a topic. Some of these rules are the same in both states. A few are not.

Management. In both states, an LLC is member-managed unless the governing documents say otherwise. In a member-managed LLC, acts outside the ordinary course of business generally need the consent of all members, and so does amending the operating agreement. That means one partner holding 10% can block a major decision unless your agreement says otherwise. Ordinary decisions are where the states differ. In Utah, each member has equal management rights, and ordinary-course disagreements are decided by a majority of the members. In California, "majority of the members" is a defined term: members holding more than 50% of the interests in current profits, not a headcount. The articles or a written operating agreement can set a different voting structure.

Distributions. This is where Utah and California part ways. Unless the operating agreement says otherwise, Utah generally divides distributions made before dissolution and winding up equally among members and dissociated members, regardless of how much each person contributed (Utah Code 16-20-404). California's default instead bases those distributions on the value of contributions received from each member, as stated in the company's required records when the distribution is decided (Corporations Code 17704.04). Different rules apply once the company winds up. In Utah, for example, creditors are paid first, and unreturned contributions generally come back before the rest is split. If one partner put in more cash and you're in Utah with no agreement on this point, the default may not match what either of you assumed.

Adding a new owner. In both states, unless the operating agreement or another statutory route provides otherwise, admitting a new member after formation requires the consent of all members. Bringing in a key manager as an owner without updating the paperwork can leave that person in an unclear spot.

When someone leaves or dies. In both states, a member is dissociated when the company has notice of their express will to withdraw, and an individual is dissociated at death. Having the power to leave isn't the same as a right to leave without consequences: in Utah, a departure can be wrongful and expose the member to damages. After dissociation, the person loses management and voting rights and generally holds their interest only as a transferee, with economic rights but no say. Leaving doesn't automatically require the company or the remaining members to buy that interest. Both states have purchase procedures in certain court-ordered dissolution cases, but those are litigation tools, not a right to demand a check. Without a buy-sell provision, a departed partner or an heir can keep collecting distributions for years with no plan to cash them out.

Ending the company. Utah's default member route to dissolution requires the consent of all members (Utah Code 16-20-701). California's default allows dissolution by a vote of 50% or more of the members' voting interests, unless the articles or a written operating agreement require more (Corporations Code 17707.01). So in a two-member California LLC with equal voting interests, one member's 50% can meet the threshold alone. In Utah, the default member route needs both. That surprises people. Court-ordered dissolution grounds still exist in both states, and a dissolution vote doesn't buy anyone out.

What your operating agreement should cover

Every agreement is different, but these sections show up in nearly every one we draft for an established company with more than one owner:

  • Ownership and capital. Who owns what percentage, what each person contributed, and what happens if the company needs more money later.

  • Management and voting. Member-managed or manager-managed, which decisions need a majority, which need a supermajority or unanimous vote, and who can sign contracts, loans, and leases.

  • Distributions and tax payments. How profits are split, when they're paid, and whether the company makes tax distributions so owners can cover taxes on income they're allocated.

  • Roles and compensation. Who runs operations, who handles the money, and how working owners are paid separately from their ownership share.

  • Transfers and new owners. Limits on selling or gifting an interest, a right of first refusal, and how a new owner is admitted.

  • Buy-sell terms. What happens on death, disability, divorce, retirement, or a partner walking away, including how the interest is valued and how the buyout is funded.

  • Deadlock and disputes. A path to break a tie, such as mediation, a tiebreaker, or a buyout mechanism.

  • Exit and dissolution. What vote it takes to sell the company or close it, and how assets are divided.

Utah and California owners with ties to both states

If your LLC is formed in Utah but does work in California, or the other way around, the company's internal affairs are generally governed by the law of the state where it was formed (Utah Code 16-20-105; California Corporations Code 17708.01). That covers how the company is run among its owners, not every law that applies to your operations in the other state. Your operating agreement should name the formation state clearly. For owners who live in one state and work in the other, it's also worth checking how a spouse's interest is treated. California is a community property state. Utah divides marital property equitably. That difference matters for your buy-sell terms.

Where to start

Find whatever you have, even if it's a template from the year you formed. Read it against the list above and write down every place the paper and the business have drifted apart. If there's no agreement at all, you're not alone and it's not too late. The fix is a conversation between owners, then a document that writes down what you already agreed to.

You can see how this fits with the rest of your ownership picture on our ownership and governance pillar page. And if you're still deciding whether your entity type is right, read Do I need an LLC or a corporation?.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Want to know where your business stands?

Book a free 15-minute legal health call with Eric Jeppson. Find the legal problems in your business before a buyer, a lender, or a lawsuit does.

Book a free 15-minute legal health call
Previous
Previous

My business partner wants out and I don’t: what are my rights?

Next
Next

Understanding your construction lien rights in Utah and California